Captain Manlove's Love-boat Murder mystery extraordinaire

Just checked my inbox to see if I hadn't got a suprise PM concerning the matter.

Yeah, it's still good. I could either keep it on myself or pass it on during the night.
So, if we mislynch someone and it turns out that the other person was scum all along, we have that solem 50/50 chance that scum shoots the guy with the vest and we're safe for an instant wipe the next day.

Number of posts : 10 Registration date : 2016-03-18

well I now know that l33t is definitely not scum because he shot someone confirming day vig, but no one else has really confirmed anything so really mel and atlas are still viable scum. mel i'm less certain though because he claimed vest but I'm pretty sure scum could wear vests.

I'm just gonna say CA is at the top of my list for who I wanna lynch.

Admin Number of posts : 1337 Age : 113 Registration date : 2007-05-17

We're lynching today, so: can we get claims from you guys?

His Sexcellency Number of posts : 1174 Age : 29 Registration date : 2007-07-26

Watcher, watched 1337ness, saw nothing. I disappointingly useless read; much like like you, 1337ness, I had a plan that involved you getting shot during the night.

That being said, I'd like to assure you I absolutely got Mason and Neighbor mixed up. This is very likely my first time seeing Neighbor in a game, so, there's that.

Also, uh, are we absolutely sure that Melex is town? I mean, he's been reading that way to me, I'll admit, but if the full extent of your townread is that he claimed bulletproof, then that's not really enough to got on. Hell, he might even be scum with a vest. It's... not impossible? I'm not trying to discredit a conf-town player here, mind, I'm just trying to make sure he is conf-town.

His Sexcellency Number of posts : 1174 Age : 29 Registration date : 2007-07-26

Actually, disregard that. It's almost entirely impossible for Melex to be bulletproof scum.

Vote: Real Human Meme, because I'm not scum.

RHM, can I get a post from you about your reaction?

Number of posts : 10 Registration date : 2016-03-18

I'm just going with what I know and what I now feel certain about is l33t has confirmed his townie. Pretty much no one else has. CA claiming makes me a little more convinced, and it's highly unlikely that he's bluffing. If mel can convince me in some way he's not scum then I'll change my vote.

Vote: Melexiious (for the time being)

PS: if we're giving roles I may as well out that I'm just vanilla townie.

Admin Number of posts : 1337 Age : 113 Registration date : 2007-05-17

Melexx can be scum. I'm 95% sure he isn't, but BP scum makes some degree of sense vs. vig.

Having said that, town almost certainly has a Watcher. Well, not Watcher specifically, but we're definitely loaded up on power roles, and RHM's claim doesn't fit that at all.

Vig + 1-shot doc + Watcher seems super balanced, so

Vote: Real Human Meme

Well, I can convince you I'm not scum by deciding not to instantly hammer you and secure a win for scum right now.

So yeah.

I'm conf-town due to my situation, why should I bother playing around when I can literally post a few words and win me the game?
I'm town, but I want to see what you think RHM. Is Cracked lying?

Or is this the taste of a liar!

His Sexcellency Number of posts : 1174 Age : 29 Registration date : 2007-07-26

"Feel the bile rising in your gullet! Gnash your mandibles in despair! Taste the bitter prank of Zondor!"

Feeling bad for the RHM/Autistocrat scum team. That was just some shitty luck on their part.

Admin Number of posts : 1337 Age : 113 Registration date : 2007-05-17

Captain Manlove wrote:

Cracked Atlas wrote:: @Mod, does this game follow the MafiaScum 'normal' guidelines?

Sure is. All the roles are ones accepted in a normal game.

These are not the same thing

Can we get further clarification here?

Unvote

Definitely want an answer before voting again because fuck my instincts are buzzing and I know I said I need to repress them right now but this one, this one is important.

Number of posts : 104 Age : 90 Localisation : The Registration date : 2013-11-12

Cracked Atlas wrote:: Feeling bad for the RHM/Autistocrat scum team.

Someone hasn't been paying attention.

Anyway..

Vote count 2.0:

(1) Melexiious - RHM L-2!
(1) Real Human Meme - cracked Atlas L-2!

Not voting: Melexiious, 1337ness

Only like 6ish days left fellas, pressure's on

EDIT: whoops, missed your post 1337ness, updating votes accordingly.

And to my knoweldge, the game is still within the guidelines, the only thing I made less than standard was the outlandish role choices but they were all still within the normal guidelines.

DOUBLE EDIT: Christ why is mobile so bad on this site.

His Sexcellency Number of posts : 1174 Age : 29 Registration date : 2007-07-26

Oh yeah, you're right. Too many acronyms.

Number of posts : 10 Registration date : 2016-03-18

Sorry mel but I'm just doing what I think is right. Everyone else can not vote for you but for what I know you're the likely candidate. Unless CA is pulling the biggest bluff, in which case it means he's mafia but I have a strong feeling there's too much risk for him to bluff.

Admin Number of posts : 1337 Age : 113 Registration date : 2007-05-17

Look, I'll come out and ask: can you confirm that there is at least one Vanilla Townie in the game?

Real Human Meme wrote:: Sorry mel but I'm just doing what I think is right. Everyone else can not vote for you but for what I know you're the likely candidate. Unless CA is pulling the biggest bluff, in which case it means he's mafia but I have a strong feeling there's too much risk for him to bluff.

If we're talking about calling bluffs, there's Cracked making a rather safe claim, and then there's me literally shouting at 1337ness to shoot me to prove I'm a townie.

There's literally no chance that I'd be bluffing scum in that situation. I was literally /asking/ the vig to shoot me. That's actual suicide if I was, and quite frankly, not worth the risk.

But yeah, I second that request, is there at least 1 vanilla townie?

Number of posts : 104 Age : 90 Localisation : The Registration date : 2013-11-12

For all intents and purposes, i will confirm there is indeed at least one vanilla townie, but then again the role that Melexiious has claimed is technically VT so its a bit of a moot point.

Do with this info as you will

Admin Number of posts : 1337 Age : 113 Registration date : 2007-05-17

Don't know what to make of that but whatever I'mma just lynch Cracked and complain to the mod if I'm wrong.

Vote: Cracked Atlas

Gah.

I'm not voting till I get a response from Atlas.

Admin Number of posts : 1337 Age : 113 Registration date : 2007-05-17

Nvm I'm actually an idiot.

Town doesn't have Cop + Watcher, that's just silly.

That's a pretty good point.
Still not voting till I get a word from Atlas.

His Sexcellency Number of posts : 1174 Age : 29 Registration date : 2007-07-26

He just said Melex is the Vanilla Townie. Just, one with a transferable item. And odd choice of character, but, it means that even the VT in this game has a power role. Meaning that a second, entirely powerless VT is unlikely.

I don't want to loose this game just because the mod made a questionable role choice.

Admin Number of posts : 1337 Age : 113 Registration date : 2007-05-17

Okay, mod has stated that there is at least one vanilla Townie and that the role Melexx has claimed could be counted as vanilla.

I don't find Cop + Watcher believable.

Having said that, I'm ultimately voting where Melexx does.

1337ness_of_teh_n00b wrote:: Okay, mod has stated that there is at least one vanilla Townie and that the role Melexx has claimed could be counted as vanilla.

I don't find Cop + Watcher believable.

Having said that, I'm ultimately voting where Melexx does.

Fuck that, I'm voting where you're ... do

But seriously I can't decide who is scum and who isn't and I'm honestly thinking about flipping a coin and going with that.

50/50 I'm right.
50/50 Scum fails in shooting.

Number of posts : 10 Registration date : 2016-03-18

I can't really make heads on who is mafia as well. I trust l33t and l33t trusts mel so I guess I have to trust mel. I'm also not certain if CA is mafia but I dno, it's possible. Right now I'll leave my vote at CA but I'll think about it.

Vote: Cracked Atlas